Close Menu
Sedona.Biz – The Voice of Sedona and The Verde ValleySedona.Biz – The Voice of Sedona and The Verde Valley
    Sedona.Biz – The Voice of Sedona and The Verde ValleySedona.Biz – The Voice of Sedona and The Verde Valley
    • Home
    • Sedona
      • Mind and Body
      • Real Estate
      • Sedona News
    • About
    • Advertise
    • Gift Guide
    • Sedona’s Best
    Sedona.Biz – The Voice of Sedona and The Verde ValleySedona.Biz – The Voice of Sedona and The Verde Valley
    Home » Who Got Paid When the Neighborhood Changed?
    Bear Howard

    Who Got Paid When the Neighborhood Changed?

    November 15, 2026No Comments
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Email Reddit WhatsApp
    Who Got Paid When the Neighborhood Changed?
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email Reddit WhatsApp

    From Baltimore’s blockbusters to Sedona’s vacation rental brokers, the real estate pitch tells us who stood to gain.

    By Bear Howard and Associates —

    Sedona AZ — On September 26, 1958, a Baltimore real estate ad asked a two-word question: “Changing Neighborhood?” A white homeowner in Edmondson Village knew what the advertiser meant. A Black family might buy on the block. What the homeowner had less reason to know was how much money the man asking the question stood to make if the answer frightened enough people into selling. [source]

    There was a name for this business: blockbusting. There ought to be more room in the American account of white flight for the people who went door to door to hurry it along. The term “white flight” tells us who left. It leaves out the fellow who wanted the listing.

    The profession had spent decades teaching Americans to confuse a neighbor’s race with a threat to their savings. In 1924, the National Association of Real Estate Boards put that idea in its Code of Ethics. Article 34 instructed a Realtor to avoid introducing people into a neighborhood whose race or nationality would supposedly make their presence “detrimental to property values.” Imagine being a Black veteran trying to buy a house and discovering that the man barring the door considered himself ethically bound to do it. [source]

    By the postwar years, an enterprising operator could make money on both sides of that prejudice. To the white homeowner, he sold urgency. Get out while you can still get your price. To the Black family, shut out of other neighborhoods and often denied an ordinary mortgage, he sold access at a premium. The house could be perfectly sound throughout. What changed between his purchase and his resale was whom he had across the table.

    Historian W. Edward Orser reconstructed this process in Baltimore’s Edmondson Village. Researchers at the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago later examined transactions on 2,600 properties there. They estimated that blockbusters bought roughly two-thirds of the properties. Their 2022 study calculated an average resale markup of about 45 percent. Sales made directly between individuals generally landed between the two prices. Think about what that means. A white seller could have received more, and a Black buyer could have paid less, if the two had sat down together. Keeping them apart was worth money. [source]

    The damage survived the closing. In Chicago’s North Lawndale, Clyde Ross bought his family’s home on contract in 1961. Under arrangements like his, the seller kept the deed while the buyer made the payments. A missed installment could cost a family the house and everything it had paid toward it. Ross helped organize the Contract Buyers League. Families who had worked extra hours to keep their homes found themselves taking on the people who had sold them. [source]

    White homeowners made choices. Lenders and federal housing policy helped determine who could borrow and where. Brokers hardly invented American racism. Some did, however, recognize a handsome margin in it and set about collecting. Chicago Fed researchers documented blockbusting in 45 of the country’s 60 largest cities. Congress finally outlawed inducing a sale for profit by invoking the arrival of people of a particular race in the Fair Housing Act of 1968. By then, a great many checks had cleared. [source]

    What does that history have to do with an Airbnb in Sedona? A family crossing a color line was claiming the right to live in a neighborhood. A buyer acquiring a house for year-round tourist bookings is buying the right to take a residence out of circulation. The question worth carrying from Baltimore to Sedona concerns the professional in the middle. How much responsibility does a broker bear for a change in a neighborhood that the broker actively helps bring about?

    Consider what a seller in Sedona can buy from a real estate professional today. There are Sedona rental-focused real estate firms that offer to market a house to buyers looking for short-term rental income. Even if nobody has ever rented the house, the firm offers to calculate what it might earn from vacationers. It distinguishes a projection from actual receipts. That is an honest disclosure. It is also a revealing service. Before a family has packed a single box, somebody can put a dollar figure on what the house might be worth once people stop living there and it becomes a mini-hotel. [source]

    Now put a local couple across the table from the investor. Their offer depends on what they earn working in town. The investor’s offer can reflect what a succession of visitors might spend on vacation here. The couple needs to afford the place on an ordinary Tuesday in February. The investor can factor in spring break. When the investor wins, the seller may do very well. The agent earns a commission.

    Where, exactly, does the couple send their losing bid to be counted?

    Arizona helped write the terms of that contest. In 2016, the Legislature passed Senate Bill 1350, barring cities from banning short-term rentals. Sedona can require permits and enforce certain rules, but the city says it cannot cap their number. In a February 2026 draft housing analysis, Sedona reported that short-term rentals grew from 9.8 percent of its housing stock in 2020 to 18.1 percent in 2025. Private rooms on its tally fell from 72 to 25. Single-family homes rose from 454 to 1,041. Whatever promise the phrase “home sharing” once held, the spare bedroom was the shrinking part of this business. [source]

    It would make a convenient villain of Wall Street to say that corporations bought most of those houses. According to data shared by Sedona city officials, 66% of short-term rentals in Sedona are owned by non-residents, leaving 34% owned by local residents. Rather than separating outside corporations from individual out-of-town investors, city reports track ownership simply by whether the owner resides locally or outside the area. Overall, these short-term rentals account for roughly 17.6% to 18% of Sedona’s total housing stock in 2025.

    Corporations and enterprising individuals found the evolution of short-term rentals as an income business a promising new enterprise. For generations, a residential property manager’s familiar chores included finding a tenant, collecting monthly rent, and sending a plumber. A vacation rental manager can take on pricing by the night, advertising across booking sites, cleaning between guests and answering the phone when a visitor cannot get through the door. A distant owner can buy into the hospitality business without ever having to change a sheet.

    Vacasa spelled out the economics in its own filings. By the end of 2023 it managed about 42,000 homes. It earned commissions on the rent it generated. It also disclosed why it had operated a real estate brokerage before winding that operation down in 2023: brokerage helped attract and retain homeowners for its vacation rental platform. There it is in the annual report. A sale could pay once at closing and deliver a management customer whose bookings kept paying. A company could have a financial interest in thousands of front doors without holding the deed to any of them. [source]

    Arizona’s tax code adds an irony. A qualifying house rented to lodgers can remain in Class Four for property tax purposes. The statute separately provides for owner-occupied primary residences in Class Three and commercial property in Class One. Short stays do generate transaction privilege and lodging taxes, including Sedona’s bed tax. The operator can therefore tell the investor that the house is a hospitality business, and the assessor can classify the property as residential. Both can be telling the truth. The neighbor who now lives beside a different set of guests every weekend is entitled to find that distinction a little precious. [source] [source]

    There is a measurable cost behind the irritation. Economists Kyle Barron, Edward Kung and Davide Proserpio found that growth in Airbnb listings raised rents and house prices, with smaller effects where more owners occupied their homes. Sedona has gone so far as to offer owners cash to put short-term rentals back on the long-term market for local employees. Consider the sequence. The agent can earn a commission selling the income potential. The manager can earn a fee by realizing it. Then the town offers public money to get a lease back. [source] [source]

    A house in Edmondson Village should have been available to the Black family that wanted to live there, at the price a willing seller would take. A house in Sedona raises a different question: What chance does the family that wants to live there have against buyers invited to price it by the night?

    The real estate profession likes to take credit for helping people find a home.

    Fair enough. When it makes money helping a town run out of homes for its own people, it can take some credit for that, too.

     

     

     

     

     

    Stay with Sedona.biz

    The week's Sedona and Verde Valley news in your inbox every Monday. Free.

    Free. One email a week. Unsubscribe any time.

    • Follow Sedona.biz on Google News so our stories show up in your feed.
    • Check live road conditions for SR 89A, SR 179 and Oak Creek Canyon.
    • See what's on this week in Sedona and the Verde Valley.
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Related Coverage

    The World Wants to Believe in America Again

    The World Wants to Believe in America Again

    November 8, 2026
    American Democracy in 2026: When Winning Matters More Than the Rules

    American Democracy in 2026: When Winning Matters More Than the Rules

    October 25, 2026
    Kings

    Kings

    October 20, 2026
    Shaking Hands With Knives Behind Their Backs

    Shaking Hands With Knives Behind Their Backs

    October 19, 2026
    New Owners. Neighboring Papers. What Changes for Sedona?

    New Owners. Neighboring Papers. What Changes for Sedona?

    October 11, 2026
    Though Shalt Not Kill

    Thou Shalt Not Kill

    October 11, 2026
    Sedona Realtor
    In The Living Room Music Series

    In The Living Room Music Series at the Mary D. Fisher Theatre (advertisement)

    Every other Monday, the Mary D. Fisher Theatre transforms into your living room for a FUN, intimate, interactive night of music and conversation! Enjoy LIVE music and ask the artist your questions during the concert. Epic music. Real conversations. Unforgettable Mondays. Click the photo to claim your seat!

    In The Living Room Music Series: tickets and dates

     

    Sedona’s Backstage Pass

     

    Sedona's Backstage Pass podcast logo

    Tune in weekly for Shondra’s behind-the-scenes conversations with the Creators, Curators, and Visionaries who are the heartbeat of Sedona’s Creativity. Spotify Click HERE. Apple Podcast Click HERE.

    Sedona's Backstage Pass podcast sponsor banner

     

     

    Recent Comments
    • West Sedona Dave on The End Times: not what you think
    • TJ Hall on The World Wants to Believe in America Again
    • JB on The Midterm Massacre: What Happened?
    • Nancy Drew on The Midterm Massacre: What Happened?
    • @Intble on The Midterm Massacre: What Happened?
    • JB on The Midterm Massacre: What Happened?
    • Intbel on The Midterm Massacre: What Happened?
    • Jill Dougherty on The Name Remains. What Happened to the Republican Party? A Mid-Term Voter Guide?
    • Intbel on The Name Remains. What Happened to the Republican Party? A Mid-Term Voter Guide?
    • Intbel on Life Lessons from Sophia, the Aussiedoodle
    Don’t miss a beat – signup for our weekly newsletter

    Free. One email a week. Unsubscribe any time.

    Cactus Quill
    The Cactus Quill
    Categories
    Your ad could be here
    Advertise on Sedona.biz: your ad could be here
    The Voice of Sedona and The Verde Valley

    News

    • Sedona News
    • Verde Valley News
    • Editorials/Opinion
    • Letter to The Editor
    • Road Conditions and Weather
    • Events This Week

    Community

    • Arts and Culture
    • Mind and Body
    • Spiritual
    • Community Events
    • Sedona Restaurants

    More

    • Weekly Newsletter
    • Sedona Real Estate
    • Gift Guide
    • Advertise
    • About
    • Contact
    • Editorial Policy

    Connect

    f X ▶
    Get the best of Sedona delivered to your inbox.

    Free. One email a week. Unsubscribe any time.

    Our Network: TheSedonan.com • SedonaBest.com
    © 2026 Sedona.Biz · Privacy Policy · Editorial Policy · Contact

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.