By Ysabella Rongo
Privatization doesn’t destroy accountability. It hides it in a contract.
Sedona, AZ — Ukraine’s military satellite link has now been throttled twice. For ten days in October, Starshield, the military version of SpaceX’s Starlink, stopped working for anything moving faster than 100 miles per hour. That covers the interceptor drones Ukraine uses to shoot down Russian attack drones and the drones it flies against Russian supply lines. Units cancelled missions. This month, Ukraine says, the cap came back along the entire front line, while American envoys were in Moscow.
Who did it? Elon Musk says the U.S. military and, ultimately, the president decide. The Wall Street Journal reported that Musk ordered the slowdown himself, and later that Trump told him to lift it. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth says the decision belongs to SpaceX under its terms of service. Secretary of State Marco Rubio says Washington “cannot direct a private company,” and has suggested Ukraine never had Starshield at all. On the second round, SpaceX told Axios “there has been no change.” It’s the Spider-Man meme.
It shouldn’t be a mystery. Starshield is a government-contracted military service. Either its contract says who can throttle it, under what conditions, and who has to be told, or it doesn’t, which is a serious gap in a contract for wartime infrastructure. It has never been made public.
Even the country at war can’t see it. Ukraine’s access is arranged through the U.S. government, not with SpaceX. The control terms sit in the Pentagon’s contract with SpaceX, and Ukraine isn’t a party to it. Accountability is split across layers of contracts, and no single party can see all of them.
The usual channels have already come up empty. In October, nine senators from both parties asked the Pentagon’s Inspector General to investigate. The Inspector General declined, after Pentagon policy officials called the disruptions a contractual matter. A month later, Ukraine still has no answer from the Pentagon or SpaceX.
Publishing the contract alone won’t settle this. A contract can give the government the right to decide while the vendor keeps the ability to act, and Hegseth’s own account puts the decision with the vendor. So the contract should require a change log. SpaceX records every change to service parameters, a government contracting officer countersigns it, oversight committees can read it, and any unrecorded change is a breach. That turns “who did it?” from finger-pointing into a records request.
A log only answers that question after the fact. Ukraine learned about both restrictions from its own drones. The contract should also require advance notice to the country operating the service, except in a genuine emergency.
The standard objection is operational security. Publishing the exact conditions for a throttle would tell Russia what triggers one. So split the terms. The governance terms go public: who decides, who must be notified, and how fast. The operational limits go to the Armed Services committees, which already handle classified material.
Contract design closes this gap, but the clause has to go in the right document. Ukraine’s arrangement with Washington expires in mid-2027, and talks on a replacement have started. That renewal is the leverage. The clause belongs in the Pentagon’s contract with SpaceX, and Congress can make it a condition of funding. When the new Congress convenes in January, Senators Kelly and Gallego should push for public governance terms, a countersigned change log and advance notice.
If a private company is doing a public function and meddling in national security and international affairs, the terms it operates under belong to the public.
Sources for fact-checking (not for print)
- Ukraine’s drones were hit by a 10-day Starlink speed limit (United24)
- Units cancelled missions (Implicator)
- Starshield throttled again as U.S. envoys visit Moscow (UPI)
- WSJ: Musk ordered the restrictions; Rubio on Starshield access (Kyiv Post)
- WSJ: Trump told Musk to lift restrictions; Reuters White House report (Kyiv Independent)
- Hegseth: “Starlink has the option to make those decisions” (Devdiscourse/Reuters)
- Rubio State Department transcript: “cannot direct a private company”
- Rubio suggested Ukraine never had Starshield (Al Jazeera)
- SpaceX to Axios: “There has been no change” (Forbes)
- Senators seek Inspector General investigation (NewSpace Economy)
- Inspector General declines probe (Stars and Stripes)
- Contract expires mid-2027; still no answers (Breaking Defense)







