Close Menu
Sedona.Biz – The Voice of Sedona and The Verde ValleySedona.Biz – The Voice of Sedona and The Verde Valley
    Sedona.Biz – The Voice of Sedona and The Verde ValleySedona.Biz – The Voice of Sedona and The Verde Valley
    • Home
    • Sedona
      • Mind and Body
      • Real Estate
      • Sedona News
    • About
    • Advertise
    • Gift Guide
    • Sedona’s Best
    Sedona.Biz – The Voice of Sedona and The Verde ValleySedona.Biz – The Voice of Sedona and The Verde Valley
    Home » To Kill or Not to Kill: That’s Tennessees’s Question
    Editorials/Opinion

    To Kill or Not to Kill: That’s Tennessees’s Question

    October 4, 20262 Comments
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Email Reddit WhatsApp
    WHAT HAPPENS WHEN THE STATE EXECUTES YOU - AND YOU DON'T DIE?
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email Reddit WhatsApp

    By Tommy Acosta

    The botched execution of convicted murderer Christa Pike presents us with a strange legal, moral and philosophical question about the death penalty.

    What happens when the state executes you — and you don’t die?

    Pike was sentenced to death for the brutal 1995 torture and murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer. On Sept. 30, Tennessee attempted to carry out that sentence by lethal injection.

    It didn’t work.

    According to Pike’s attorneys, she was given two doses of pentobarbital. She survived both and was eventually transported to a hospital, where she has remained unconscious, critically ill and on a ventilator.

    Suppose Pike eventually succumbs to the poison that was put into her body during the execution and dies tomorrow, next week or a month from now. Was she executed? I would think the answer would have to be yes.

    The state intentionally administered lethal drugs for the specific purpose of killing her. If those drugs ultimately cause her death, the fact that they took days rather than minutes to accomplish the job shouldn’t magically transform an execution into something else.

    The execution would simply have taken quite longer than Tennessee planned.

    But suppose Pike survives. Then what?

    Does Tennessee strap her down again, find another vein and say, essentially, “Sorry about the first one, Christa. Let’s try this again”?

    Legally, apparently, the question isn’t settled simply because the first attempt failed. But morally and constitutionally, another execution attempt would open an extraordinary argument over whether the state can subject a person to the ordeal of execution twice.

    And that’s where this gets uncomfortable. Some people will say Pike suffered terribly during the execution attempt.

    There is evidence she did. Her attorneys say both arms were swollen, burned and blistered afterward, and witnesses described obvious distress during the procedure.

    Others will respond: What about Colleen Slemmer? She suffered, too. Horribly. And unlike Pike, she didn’t have doctors waiting nearby to save her life.

    That inevitably raises the ancient question of retribution. Is Pike’s suffering some form of poetic justice for the suffering she inflicted upon another human being?

    Or does civilized justice require us to say something harder: What Pike did to her victim and what the state is permitted to do to Pike are two entirely different moral questions?

    That’s the part people sometimes miss in debates about capital punishment.

    The Constitution doesn’t say cruel punishment becomes acceptable when the condemned person committed an especially cruel crime. If anything, that’s when our principles are actually tested.

    Now let’s make the hypothetical even stranger.

    Suppose Pike remains hospitalized and at some point her heart stops. No pulse. No heartbeat.

    Doctors immediately begin resuscitation and, several minutes they give up trying. They declare her dead. Ten minutes later she wakes up fully conscious and yawning. Did Tennessee finally execute her? Did she complete her sentence and earned herself a ticket out the hospital door.

    Can she now  say, “Well, boys, you sentenced me to death. I died. Sentence served. Where are my clothes?”

    But philosophically, the hypothetical exposes something fascinating.

    What exactly is a death sentence? Is the punishment the process of being executed? Is it experiencing the expectation of death? Is it receiving the lethal chemicals?

    Or is the sentence fulfilled only by one irreversible biological event: Death.

    Because Tennessee has certainly punished Pike.

    It prepared her for death. It put her into the execution chamber. It inserted the needles. It administered the drugs intended to kill her.

    And according to witnesses and her attorneys, she suffered through an execution procedure that went terribly wrong.

    Yet she’s alive. So apparently the sentence isn’t “execution.”

    The sentence is death.

    And there is a difference.

    That difference becomes even more disturbing when we consider what happens next.

    Suppose Pike never regains consciousness.

    Suppose she remains dependent upon a ventilator and intensive medical care for months or even years.

    The state that tried to kill her now has an obligation to keep her alive.

    Think about this for a moment.

    One arm of the government deliberately injects chemicals into a human being for the purpose of stopping her heart.

    When that doesn’t work, another group of people races her to a hospital and uses medicine, machines and enormous amounts of money to prevent her from dying.

    First the state says, “You must die.”

    Then, hours later, it says, “For God’s sake, don’t let her die.”

    There is something almost Kafkaesque about it.

    And Tennessee cannot simply solve the problem by withholding food, water or necessary medical treatment until Pike dies. That would raise an entirely different set of constitutional, medical and ethical questions and would not magically convert neglect into a lawful execution.

    The state chose execution.

    The execution failed.

    That failure belongs to the state, not the prisoner.

    And this is where the people who actually carried out the procedure deserve scrutiny.

    Pike’s attorneys had warned before the execution about medical complications, including problems establishing intravenous access. Yet Tennessee proceeded.

    Then the extraordinary happened.

    Two doses of the drug intended to kill her failed to do so.

    Tennessee’s own execution protocol apparently didn’t provide another step after that.

    No Plan C.

    No “In case inmate remains inconveniently alive, turn to page 47.”

    The execution was over.

    Except the condemned woman wasn’t dead.

    Gov. Bill Lee has since halted Tennessee’s remaining executions for the year and ordered a review of what happened.

    Because whether you support the death penalty or oppose it, surely everyone should be able to agree on one thing:

    If the government assumes the enormous power to deliberately take a human life in the name of its citizens, it had  better know what it is doing.

    There is also another uncomfortable question.

    At what point does punishment become vengeance?

    Christa Pike committed a horrific murder. Nothing about this column changes that, minimizes it or restores the life of Colleen Slemmer.

    But the purpose of a justice system isn’t to imitate the murderer.

    It is supposed to represent something better.

    More deliberate. More rational. More controlled.

    Justice is supposed to be what remains after anger has cooled.

    And now Pike lies unconscious in a hospital while Tennessee, her attorneys, doctors and perhaps eventually the courts confront a question nobody expected to be asking:

    Has this woman already been punished enough to satisfy a sentence of death?

    Legally, the answer may ultimately be no.

    Morally, the answer isn’t nearly so simple.

    If she dies from the drugs Tennessee injected into her, then the state will have accomplished what it set out to do, albeit in a horrifyingly prolonged fashion.

    If she survives, Tennessee faces a much more profound decision.

    It can insist that death means death and try again.

    Or it can recognize that there are moments when the machinery of government fails so catastrophically that simply pulling the lever a second time ceases to look like justice.

    Maybe that’s the real lesson buried inside this gruesome episode.

    We use the phrase “death penalty” so casually that the words become almost bureaucratic.

    Death penalty. Capital punishment. Execution.

    Nice clean terminology.

    But there is nothing bureaucratic about deliberately stopping another human being’s heart.

    And when the heart stubbornly refuses to stop, all those clean words suddenly disappear.

    What remains is a living human being on a hospital bed, a dead young woman who can never be brought back, a government trying to explain what went wrong and the rest of us confronting a question that has followed civilization for thousands of years:

    When we kill in the name of justice, what exactly makes it justice?

    Stay with Sedona.biz

    The week's Sedona and Verde Valley news in your inbox every Monday. Free.

    Free. One email a week. Unsubscribe any time.

    • Follow Sedona.biz on Google News so our stories show up in your feed.
    • Check live road conditions for SR 89A, SR 179 and Oak Creek Canyon.
    • See what's on this week in Sedona and the Verde Valley.

    2 Comments

    1. Buddy Oakes on October 5, 2026 7:49 am

      During the time leading up to the attempted execution, the issue of the small veins was discussed. Pike knew of the issue and asked to be hung which was rejected by the state. I live in Tennessee and the question I have is was it determined that hanging which has worked well in the past too brutal or barbaric? Tennessee has botched two executions this year trying to use the more civilized lethal injection method. So in reality if Pike had been hung it would now be over and few would be talking about it. If the goal of execution is to end a life why would the most foolproof method not be used?

      Reply
      • JB on October 5, 2026 1:01 pm

        Hangings have failed as well and so have execution by shooting (most rounds miss the heart completely). At least two of the Nazi’s hung following the Nuremberg trials had to be killed by the executioners placing their body weight upon theirs as they hung clinging to life at the end of the rope that failed to kill them. Both are still generally more reliable than pentobarbital has a track record for. Electrocution is considered barbaric and have failed as well even after BBQ the prisoners innards like a giant microwave.

        In this case we’re talking about a woman who had a long history of sexual, emotional and physical abuse having killed another young gal when both were just 18 years old. Yes murder is always wrong even when done by a child but the death penalty certainly wasn’t crucial to this case unlike cases such as the Manson murders, cop killers and the like which do merit the harshest penalty we have which is death by execution. This woman should’ve had a sentence of life in prison not death by execution. The death penalty should only be used for the worst of the worst.

        Reply
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Related Coverage

    One Click Away from Chaos

    One Click Away from Chaos

    November 17, 2026
    Who Got Paid When the Neighborhood Changed?

    Who Got Paid When the Neighborhood Changed?

    November 15, 2026
    The World Wants to Believe in America Again

    The World Wants to Believe in America Again

    November 8, 2026
    American Democracy in 2026: When Winning Matters More Than the Rules

    American Democracy in 2026: When Winning Matters More Than the Rules

    October 25, 2026
    Kings

    Kings

    October 20, 2026
    Shaking Hands With Knives Behind Their Backs

    Shaking Hands With Knives Behind Their Backs

    October 19, 2026
    Sedona Realtor
    In The Living Room Music Series

    In The Living Room Music Series at the Mary D. Fisher Theatre (advertisement)

    Every other Monday, the Mary D. Fisher Theatre transforms into your living room for a FUN, intimate, interactive night of music and conversation! Enjoy LIVE music and ask the artist your questions during the concert. Epic music. Real conversations. Unforgettable Mondays. Click the photo to claim your seat!

    In The Living Room Music Series: tickets and dates

     

    Sedona’s Backstage Pass

     

    Sedona's Backstage Pass podcast logo

    Tune in weekly for Shondra’s behind-the-scenes conversations with the Creators, Curators, and Visionaries who are the heartbeat of Sedona’s Creativity. Spotify Click HERE. Apple Podcast Click HERE.

    Sedona's Backstage Pass podcast sponsor banner

     

     

    Recent Comments
    • Jill Dougherty on VVREO Publishes Consolidated Flood Emergency Resource
    • JB on One Click Away from Chaos
    • Steve Segner on Who Got Paid When the Neighborhood Changed?
    • STR Suck! on Who Got Paid When the Neighborhood Changed?
    • Doc jones on Bringing Jazz Back to Sedona: A New Chapter Begins with the Flavor of New Orleans
    • JB on The End Times: not what you think
    • West Sedona Dave on The End Times: not what you think
    • TJ Hall on The World Wants to Believe in America Again
    • JB on The Midterm Massacre: What Happened?
    • Nancy Drew on The Midterm Massacre: What Happened?
    Don’t miss a beat – signup for our weekly newsletter

    Free. One email a week. Unsubscribe any time.

    Cactus Quill
    The Cactus Quill
    Categories
    Your ad could be here
    Advertise on Sedona.biz: your ad could be here
    The Voice of Sedona and The Verde Valley

    News

    • Sedona News
    • Verde Valley News
    • Editorials/Opinion
    • Letter to The Editor
    • Road Conditions and Weather
    • Events This Week

    Community

    • Arts and Culture
    • Mind and Body
    • Spiritual
    • Community Events
    • Sedona Restaurants

    More

    • Weekly Newsletter
    • Sedona Real Estate
    • Gift Guide
    • Advertise
    • About
    • Contact
    • Editorial Policy

    Connect

    f X ▶
    Get the best of Sedona delivered to your inbox.

    Free. One email a week. Unsubscribe any time.

    Our Network: TheSedonan.com • SedonaBest.com
    © 2026 Sedona.Biz · Privacy Policy · Editorial Policy · Contact

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.