Sedona.Biz – The Voice of Sedona and The Verde ValleySedona.Biz – The Voice of Sedona and The Verde Valley
    Sedona.Biz – The Voice of Sedona and The Verde Valley Sedona.Biz – The Voice of Sedona and The Verde Valley
    • Home
    • Sedona
      • Arts and Entertainment
      • Bear Howard Chronicles
      • Business Profiles
      • City of Sedona
      • Elections
      • Goodies & Freebies
      • Mind & Body
      • Sedona News
    • Opinion
    • Real Estate
    • About
    • The Sedonan
    • Advertise
    • Sedona’s Best
    Sedona.Biz – The Voice of Sedona and The Verde ValleySedona.Biz – The Voice of Sedona and The Verde Valley
    Home»Sedona News»Transitional Lighting Analysis
    Sedona News

    Transitional Lighting Analysis

    November 5, 20111 Comment
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Email Reddit WhatsApp
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email Reddit WhatsApp

    Negative Effect of Driving from a Lighted Street is not Bogus

    by Rod Veach, West Sedona

    ANIMATED LOGOSedona, AZ (November 5, 2011) – On Thursday November 3, 2011 Dr. Serge Wright (speaking for Let The People Vote) at formal public debate (OLLI Lunch and Talk) used the term BOGUS when asked to address the potential negative effect of driving from a lighted street (potentially W 89A if Continuous Roadway Lighting is installed) onto a totally dark street (all of Sedona’s side streets). Mr. Wright provided an explanation of why transitional lighting is not an issue. To an unknowing person what Mr. Wright said seemed completely logical. He said that because the lights were 35 feet in the air we would not have a problem. Think about this. The lights are designed to light the roadway where we are driving. If we don’t have enough light on the roadway surface to worry about, why bother with the installation of the lights. My thought is that his answer was completely fabricated. I hope Mr. Wright has the courage to read this and respond to what he has read. I am not a lighting expert, but the information below demonstrates that transitional lighting is not a BOGUS issue. Real experts in highway lighting design believe it is an issue that requires attention. Mr. Wright has the credentials to help people with their vision issues, but he certainly cannot debunk what highway engineers, trained in that field, say about how a highway lighting system should be designed.

    “Transitional lighting” is a lighting term that refers to the need for a transition between lighted and dark areas. When driving from a lighted area (West 89A if streetlights are installed) into a dark area (all Sedona side streets), a driver’s eyes require up to fifteen seconds to adjust to the new light level. While this adjustment is taking place, the driver’s vision is impaired, thereby creating a perilous situation. Older drivers’ eyes find it more difficult to adjust in this transition zone. This lack of transitional lighting is a serious issue for West Sedona, which has more than 30 unlit side streets, most without sidewalks. Imagine, if you will, an older person turning onto a dark side street and struggling to see, while someone is walking on that dark street. ADOT is willing to create this situation in order to install continuous roadway lighting, attempting to address a nighttime issue that does not exist.

    If the City of Sedona accepts CRL after understanding the safety issues involved in transitions from lighted to dark streets, it necessarily increases its liability.

    The FHWA and numerous state DOT’s, including ADOT, recognize that if transitional lighting is not provided, an unsafe condition is created (see information below). Even though ADOT’s Engineering Practice regarding highway lighting (Section 700-Illumination) specifically refers to the necessity of transitional lighting in a situation like West 89A, ADOT is refusing to address this issue. To provide transitional lighting, several hundred feet of each side street would need to have streetlights installed, lighting up the whole town, truly not a desirable solution. Even if it were desirable, ADOT does not own the side streets, the City does. The cost of lighting side streets to address this problem of transitional lighting for approximately 15 miles is huge. (ADOT Engineering Practices recommends ½ mile of transitional lighting per street, and Sedona has 30 side streets). So the streets would stay dark, and the problem remains unresolved.

    By installing CRL, ADOT is actually making Sedona more dangerous.

    The following information fully shows that transitional lighting is not a BOGUS issue. As can be seen from the data collected by doing a simple internet search, there is nothing BOGUS about transitional lighting. It is real, and presents a real danger to all drivers, especially older drivers.

    (Websites are in blue, authors comments are in green and quoted text is dark red.)

    Below you will find information relating to engineering policies for the installation of continuous roadway lighting in those situations in which the newly lighted roadway would be contiguous with dark streets or roadways.

    Information directly below is from the ADOT website verbatim.

    ADOT Traffic Engineering Policies, Guidelines, and Procedures January 2003

    Section 700 – Illumination

    700-3

    b) Continuous Lighting on Conventional Highways

    Continuous lighting on conventional highways is considered to be

    justified where local agencies find sufficient benefit in the forms of

    convenience, safety, policing, community promotion, public relations,

    etc. to pay the cost of installation, maintenance, and operation of the

    lighting. Continuous lighting may be permitted by the State after the

    consideration of the following conditions: [highlighting mine]

    1. Is lighting on a city street grid visible from highway?

    2. Are the cross streets lighted up to one-half (1/2) mile in each

    direction from the highway?

    3. Is the area under consideration urban?

    4. What is the night time number of crashes vs. the day time

    number for that section in the past three (3) years?

    _______________________________________________________________________

    You will find data from different state agencies, municipalities, and from FHWA below.

    Richmond.ca/_shared/assets/roadway_lighting20126.pdf

    6.8 SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS

    Illumination levels differ for different classifications of roadways and where these roads meet

    there shall be a transition area. The road with a lower illumination level shall have a gradual

    increase in illumination level until the higher level is reached.

    /www.ottawa.ca/residents/planning/design_plan_guidelines/completed/lighting/chapter2/2_11_en.html

    2.11 Transition Illumination

    ________________________________________

    Where sections of roadways that are fully illuminated are located adjacent to sections that are not, the street lighting shall be transitioned as recommended by the Guide for the Design of Roadway Lighting2 Transitioning of the roadway illumination will allow for easier adaptation of the driver’s eye from a lit to a dark section of roadway. A consistent style of lighting equipment will be used in the transition area selected from Appendix B Approved Lighting Equipment.

    2.11.1 Full Continuous Lighting up to a Boundary Road

    For unique situations where an urban road designation is being fully illuminated up to the boundary of an urban / rural area, the full illumination shall be transitioned as recommended by the Guide for the Design of Roadway Lighting2. The transition illumination will be extended into the rural area up to and including the point where the roadway tapers from an urban cross section (four lanes with curb) to a rural cross section (two lanes without curb).

    2.11.2 Transition Illumination at Intersections

    For intersections where only one of the intersecting roads has full continuous lighting and the light levels at the intersection are 50% greater than the light levels of the approaching illuminated roadway (as required by Section 2.3 Intersections), the non-illuminated intersecting road shall have transition lighting designed to extend the lighting beyond the intersection with a maximum of two pole cycles for each approach.

    www.gogreenva.org/assets/docs/7_ArlingtonStLight.pdf

    ARLINGTON COUNTY GOVERNMENT

    STREET LIGHT POLICY AND PLANNING GUIDE

    3.4 TRANSITION LIGHTING

    When developing lighting plans, the effects of lighting on the driver’s eye must be

    understood. According to the “Roadway Lighting Handbook”, a driver’s eye

    adjusts every time it experiences a lighting change. It is more difficult; and takes

    longer for the eye to adjust from light to dark than conversely. With this in mind,

    the handbook specifies that a transition lighting section be provided when moving

    from one light level to another.

    The Illumination Engineering Society recommends that the light level be reduced

    by no more than 50% in a section of roadway that a vehicle travels along in a 15-

    second period. This means a driver traveling along the roadway would

    Sedona Gift Shop

    experience no more than a 50% drop in illumination in 15 seconds. This rationale

    will be considered when going from any type of zone in Arlington, like going

    from a commercial area along a residential street into an intermediate or a lowdensity

    area. This insures there is uniformity, and does not compromise this design imperative.

    ntl.bts.gov/DOCS/97095/ch02/body_ch02_04.html

    The objective was to determine the extent to which transient visual adaptation (TVA) affects drivers’ detection of targets along partially lighted freeway interchanges. TVA occurs when the eye moves from one luminance level to another and is continuously adapting to higher and lower levels, thereby temporarily reducing contrast sensitivity. A reduction in contrast sensitivity can reduce the probability of detecting a target on the road or roadside.

    www.modot.org/design/ppdm/files/801.pdf

    8-01.4 (2) (d) ADAPTATION (TRANSITION) LIGHTING. Adaptation lighting attempts to reduce the rapid and extreme changes in levels of illuminance which occur when entering or leaving a continuously lighted section of roadway. Adaptation lighting is also used to adapt the driver to continuous interchange lighting before important decision points. The value of adaptation lighting is debatable since it is difficult to attain a gradual uniform change. Adaptation lighting is recommended for the extremities of a continuous lighted section of roadway that is a mile [1.5 km] or more in length or complex interchanges that are continuously lit. The transition effect is attained by decreasing the intensity of the last few luminaires, rather than by using increased spacing. Typically, the transition section is 15 seconds in length and the average intensity is approximately 50 percent of the intensity in the continuously lit section

    www.northbrook.il.us/files/SOP%20TEXT/SECTION(6).pdf

    O. TRANSITIONAL LIGHTING SECTIONS

    Roadway lighting systems shall be designed to decrease the driver’s brightness when

    emerging from a lighted section of roadway. Using the design speed of the road, the

    reduced lighting level zone with smaller lamp sizes shall allow for a ten (10) second eye

    exposure adjustment.

    www.mdt.mt.gov/other/traffic/external/pdf/chapter_13.pdf

    5. Transitional Lighting Transitional lighting is a technique intended to provide the driver with a gradual reduction in lighting levels and glare when leaving a lighting system. The designer may consider transition lighting after a study of the conditions at a specific location. Typical transition lighting design should extend the lighting system a sufficient distance beyond the normal limits of illumination.

    www.tdot.state.tn.us/Chief_Engineer/assistant_engineer_design/design/Traffic_Design_Manual.pdf

    4. Transition Lighting. Transition lighting is a technique intended to provide the driver with a gradual reduction in lighting levels and glare when leaving an illuminated area. Several implementation methods exist.

    The designer also may consider extending delineation 1000 ft beyond the last luminaire for traffic lanes emerging from a lighted area (ambient light). This will provide an additional measure of effectiveness.

    Vision adjustment when approaching a lighted area is not impacted greatly and therefore requires no special consideration.

    11.Rapid changes in levels of illumination may be compensated by using transition lighting or adaptation techniques. When transition lighting is provided the roadway sector requiring transition lighting should be illuminated so as to allow the motorist’s eyes to adjust to a different level of illumination. A practical formula for calculating the required roadway length for transition lighting is as follows:

    L= (S)( C )(T)

    Where, L = Length of Transition Lighting

    S = Speed Along Roadway Section in MPH (design speed)

    C = 1.47 (Converts MPH to feet per Second)

    T = 15 Sec. (Recommended exposure time to allow motorist’s eyes to adjust to different level of illumination).

    3.4 TRANSITION LIGHTING

    When developing lighting plans, the effects of lighting on the driver’s eye must be understood. According to the “Roadway Lighting Handbook”, a driver’s eye adjusts every time it experiences a lighting change. It is more difficult; and takes longer for the eye to adjust from light to dark than conversely. With this in mind, the handbook specifies that a transition lighting section be provided when moving from one light level to another.

    The Illumination Engineering Society recommends that the light level be reduced by no more than 50% in a section of roadway that a vehicle travels along in a 15-second period. This means a driver traveling along the roadway would experience no more than a 50% drop in illumination in 15 seconds. This rationale will be considered when going from any type of zone in Arlington, like going from a commercial area along a residential street into an intermediate or a low-density area. This insures there is uniformity, and does not compromise this design imperative.

    From a NJ Turnpike Engineer

    The Turnpike has used transitional lighting for many years at our underdeck locations (some classified as “tunnels”), plaza ramps and plazas themselves. Here is a general overview.

    AASHTO and IES (Illumination Engineering Society) have guidelines for lighting that our designers follow depending on the road speed and configuration (ramps, gores, underpasses, tunnels, etc.) For example, during daylight hours, the portals of underdeck lighting are brighter than the lighting directly under the structure, as can be observed by an increase of luminaires in the portals. The luminaires are spaced wider as you travel further into the tunnel so as to “transition” the intensity of light, to allow one’s eyes to acclimate to the new environment. Night lighting fixtures will turn on at dusk and the daytime lights are extinguished in stages so as to avoid an abrupt change if someone is in the tunnel during the changeover. Night lighting is at a significantly lower footcandle level than daytime so as not to blind the motorist.

    Ramp lighting also has specific “rules” to follow depending on configuration and speed of the merge. Typically we see wattages starting at the plaza of 250 – 400 watts tapering off to 150 watt for the last several poles on an acceleration ramp as a transition zone. Deceleration ramps are the reverse.

    The DOT uses many of the same Design Engineers that we retain. They would therefore also have transitional lighting where it is called for by design.

    56-2.12 Transition Lighting

    Consider step-down transition lighting, or similar visibility measures, for traffic lanes emerging from a lighted area with very high lighting levels. For additional information, consult the ANSI/IESNA RP-8.

    http://www.state.tn.us/sos/rules/1680/1680-06/1680-06-01.pdf

    13. Transitional lighting should be provided when the average maintained horizontal footcandle level of illumination for lighting designs exceeds 1.00 footcandles. The roadway sector requiring transitional lighting should be illuminated so as to allow the motorist’s eyes to adjust to a different level of illumination and should be traditionally illuminated for no less than 15 seconds. The level of illumination for transitional lighting sector should be equal to approximately one-half of the preceding higher lighted sector.

    The terminal illumination in the lowest sector should not be less than 0.25 footcandle nor more than 0.5 footcandle. An expedient formula for calculating the required roadway lengths for transitional lighting is as follows:

    L = (RS) (C) (T)

    Where L = Length of Transitional Lighting

    RS = Running Speed Along Roadway Section in MPH

    C = 1.47 (Converts MPH to Feet per Second)

    T = 15 See (Recommended exposure time to allow motorist’s eyes to adjust to different level of illumination).

    14. Transitional lighting is best provided by maintaining the same average spacing and by using lower wattage lamps. This allows for future extension of the lighting system without having to relocate mountings.

    www.visualexpert.com/Resources/nightvision.html

    Night Vision

    Lastly, adaptation effects have large safety implications. Whenever a person transitions from a brightly lit or very dark environment to one of very different luminance, there will be a large visual loss. Elderly people exhibit impaired abilities and suffer the largest visual loss due to abrupt light changes. Proper design should create smooth transitions from light to dark. For example, building entrances and tunnels now often incorporate a zone of middle light level between the dark night outside and the bright interior lighting. This smoother transition minimizes adaptation effects and permits better vision.

     

     

     

     

     

    Healing Paws

    This is an advertisement

    rod veach transitional lighting

    1 Comment

    1. N. Baer fka Sedona RR News Subscriber on November 5, 2011 10:39 pm

      Very detailed coverage of this issue. In short, as we age, the rods and cones (photoreceptors) in our eyes take longer to adapt to extreme dark when we are coming from extreme light. Since the median age in Sedona is 55 year old, CRL emitting an amount of uplight equal to about 30 acres of commercial development without “transitional lighting” on roads intersecting with 89A could pose increased danger to Sedona residents.

      Vision Aware (www.visionaware.org) describes this as “More time required to adjust to bright light and/or darkness Adjusting to changes in light levels between bright and dark areas — such as leaving a dim building lobby and walking outside into bright sunlight or moving out of a dimly lit restaurant into daylight — can take two to three times longer than it used to.”

    Hey Papi
    Happy Father’s Day Papi!

    How’s it going up there in heaven? It’s Father’s Day here on Earth, and I’m thinking of you—missing you—now that I’m one year older than you were when you passed away. I just want to thank you for everything you taught me. Thank you for taking such good care of me. Thank you for helping me walk when I couldn’t walk. Thank you for making me strong against all adversity. Thank you for teaching me how to look behind the scenes and see what’s not being shown.

    Read more→

    The Sedonan
    Need More Customers?
    Bear Howard Chronicles
    Humankind
    Tlaquepaque
    Verde Valley Wine Trail
    Recent Comments
    • JB on Cottonwood, Verde Valley Residents Join Largest Protest Yet to Reject Abuses of Power
    • Jill Dougherty on Cottonwood, Verde Valley Residents Join Largest Protest Yet to Reject Abuses of Power
    • Rob Schwab on Cottonwood, Verde Valley Residents Join Largest Protest Yet to Reject Abuses of Power
    • Jill Dougherty on Cottonwood, Verde Valley Residents Join Largest Protest Yet to Reject Abuses of Power
    • TJ Hall on The Rise of the Enforcement Class
    • JB on Cottonwood, Verde Valley Residents Join Largest Protest Yet to Reject Abuses of Power
    • @mkJeeves on Cottonwood, Verde Valley Residents Join Largest Protest Yet to Reject Abuses of Power
    • TJ Hall on The Rise of the Enforcement Class
    • mkjeeves on Cottonwood, Verde Valley Residents Join Largest Protest Yet to Reject Abuses of Power
    • Jill Dougherty on The Rise of the Enforcement Class
    • JB on The Rise of the Enforcement Class
    • Mike Schroeder on The Rise of the Enforcement Class
    • JB on Cottonwood, Verde Valley Residents Join Largest Protest Yet to Reject Abuses of Power
    • Jill Dougherty on Cottonwood, Verde Valley Residents Join Largest Protest Yet to Reject Abuses of Power
    • West Sedona Dave on Cottonwood, Verde Valley Residents Join Largest Protest Yet to Reject Abuses of Power
    Archives
    Hey Papi
    Happy Father’s Day Papi!

    How’s it going up there in heaven? It’s Father’s Day here on Earth, and I’m thinking of you—missing you—now that I’m one year older than you were when you passed away. I just want to thank you for everything you taught me. Thank you for taking such good care of me. Thank you for helping me walk when I couldn’t walk. Thank you for making me strong against all adversity. Thank you for teaching me how to look behind the scenes and see what’s not being shown.

    Read more→

    The Sedonan
    The Sedonan
    Hey Papi
    Happy Father’s Day Papi!

    How’s it going up there in heaven? It’s Father’s Day here on Earth, and I’m thinking of you—missing you—now that I’m one year older than you were when you passed away. I just want to thank you for everything you taught me. Thank you for taking such good care of me. Thank you for helping me walk when I couldn’t walk. Thank you for making me strong against all adversity. Thank you for teaching me how to look behind the scenes and see what’s not being shown.

    Read more→

    Hey Papi
    Happy Father’s Day Papi!

    How’s it going up there in heaven? It’s Father’s Day here on Earth, and I’m thinking of you—missing you—now that I’m one year older than you were when you passed away. I just want to thank you for everything you taught me. Thank you for taking such good care of me. Thank you for helping me walk when I couldn’t walk. Thank you for making me strong against all adversity. Thank you for teaching me how to look behind the scenes and see what’s not being shown.

    Read more→

    Hey Papi
    Happy Father’s Day Papi!

    How’s it going up there in heaven? It’s Father’s Day here on Earth, and I’m thinking of you—missing you—now that I’m one year older than you were when you passed away. I just want to thank you for everything you taught me. Thank you for taking such good care of me. Thank you for helping me walk when I couldn’t walk. Thank you for making me strong against all adversity. Thank you for teaching me how to look behind the scenes and see what’s not being shown.

    Read more→

    Hey Papi
    Happy Father’s Day Papi!

    How’s it going up there in heaven? It’s Father’s Day here on Earth, and I’m thinking of you—missing you—now that I’m one year older than you were when you passed away. I just want to thank you for everything you taught me. Thank you for taking such good care of me. Thank you for helping me walk when I couldn’t walk. Thank you for making me strong against all adversity. Thank you for teaching me how to look behind the scenes and see what’s not being shown.

    Read more→

    Hey Papi
    Happy Father’s Day Papi!

    How’s it going up there in heaven? It’s Father’s Day here on Earth, and I’m thinking of you—missing you—now that I’m one year older than you were when you passed away. I just want to thank you for everything you taught me. Thank you for taking such good care of me. Thank you for helping me walk when I couldn’t walk. Thank you for making me strong against all adversity. Thank you for teaching me how to look behind the scenes and see what’s not being shown.

    Read more→

    © 2025 All rights reserved. Sedona.biz.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.