|
|
|||||||
News Arts & Leisure Sports Business Opinion Dining Gardening Travel Classifieds Jobs Community Events Forums TV Listings |
Sedona City Council seeks partners in trash
A transfer station in Sedona, lower down on the City's priority
list
by Carl Jackson | Sedona.biz
Sedona, AZ - In early January 2008, the Sedona City Council
met to discuss whether the City should assume responsibility for
trash collection in Sedona.
Under the plan, the City would provide curbside recycling and trash
collection, and biomass pickup (flammable vegetation like branches
and brush) for all Sedona residents.
The idea fizzled
into a possible cardboard ordinance to encourage recycling once the
City Council learned that about 90% of Sedona residents have trash
service and are generally satisfied with their haulers.
The issue of trash disposal has been ripening ever since the Brins Mesa fire in June 2006 highlighted the need for all residents
to become firewise by creating a defensible perimeter around their
homes by clearing out brush and branches. Temporary biomass disposal dumpsters
were provided by the Sedona Fire District in
Uptown shortly after the Brins Mesa fire which demonstrated that a conveniently
located drop-off point for biomass could make sense.
Since that time, however, trash disposal has taken on a higher
purpose: reducing illegal dumping in the National Forest, and
litter along the roadway. The City of Sedona is also concerned
about debris finding its way into the City's storm water drainage
ways.
According to Kate Blevins of Verde Earthworks, illegal
dumping in the forest is generally done by small haulers like
landscapers and contractors who want to avoid the cost of hauling
their waste to landfills; and not residents.
One idea being considered is to build a transfer station in or near
Sedona where residents, landscapers, and construction crews could
bring their trash for further transfer to a landfill in Dewey,
Arizona.
The thinking seems to be that those thoughtless enough to dump their
debris in the National Forest wouldn't do so if a transfer station
was close by unless, of course, it was free.
Sir Moves A Lot in Sedona (on Finley Drive) currently provides a
quasi transfer station where local residents, landscapers and
contractors can bring their solid waste, landscape waste, and
demolition materials as well as mattresses, appliances, tires, and
car batteries; but the facility is considered small and difficult to
get access. There are also transfers stations in Cottonwood
and Camp Verde.
At the February 26, 2006 city council meeting, the Council once
again took up the issue of a transfer station. City Manager,
Eric Levitt, presented two possible locations: behind the
Cultural Park on National Forest Land; and at the Wastewater
Treatment Plant further down 89A.
Although the Cultural Park location was considered the most
conveniently located, the City Council wasn't ready for a battle
with nearby neighborhoods, and quickly rejected it. Said City
Council member, John Bradshaw, "I'm in favor of doing more
investigation on the Wastewater Treatment Plant [as a location]...I
don't want City Staff doing lot of work on the Cultural Park when we
all know that we're going to get a lot of resistance from homeowners
and it's probably not going to go anywhere."
Most members considered the Wastewater Treatment Plant to be too far
away to be a convenient and effective location for a transfer
station. There was also a general concern about using valuable
and scarce City land for a transfer station that could use up as
much as 5 acres (probably around 1-2 acres). Said Mayor
Colquitt, "What if [the City] wants to develop the Wastewater Plant
for [affordable] housing or a park...I'm not saying we're going to
do this; it's just an example. But if we had a transfer
station there, how would it effect those kinds of plans? We
need to think ahead."
Council member, Harvey Stearn, asked why the City staff wasn't
talking with the National Forest Service about other suitable
locations on forest land. Council member, Nancy Scagnelli,
suggested that the City work with Sir Moves A Lot about possibly
upgrading their facility.
Council member, Rob Adams, was all about the numbers. "How
much is this going to cost us? I need to have a better
understanding of the costs versus the benefits before I support
anything." According to City Manager, Eric Levitt, the
transfer station site prep cost would range from $75,000 to
$150,000. After that, a private contractor like Waste
Management would be brought in to manage the facility. If the
City Council wanted the transfer station to be most cost effective,
it could subsidize the cost by contributing up to $60,000 annually.
Said Mr. Levitt, "It all depends on how low cost you want the
transfer station to be. If you want to be like Cottonwood that
is for-profit and full price, the [ongoing] cost could be zero."
Ron Mohney, Treasurer of Sedona Recycles, was on hand
to offer the Council ideas on how it could reduce the costs of
constructing and maintaining a transfer station. Said Mr.
Mohney, "I don't represent the Arizona Department of
Environmental Quality (ADEQ), but I know they want to reduce the
amount of trash going into landfills. Right now, contractors
don't want to separate out recyclable materials [generally about 40%
of total trash] because it's not convenient. If Sedona
Recycles was to place recycle bins at the transfer station, it would
make it very easy for contractors to separate out the recyclable
materials. [Sedona Recycles] would manage the bins and pick up the material for free because we can sell it. The City
could likely get grant money for ADEQ if the the transfer station
offered recycling because it would reduce the amount of trash that
would go in the landfill...We would be happy to work with the City
to write up the grant paper work for this."
In the end, the City Council felt that a transfer station could be a
good idea, but not on City land and the not without partners. Said
Mayor Colquitt, "The National Forest Service will be one of the
biggest beneficiaries of a transfer station...and what about towns
in the upper Verde Valley and Yavapai County who would also benefit
from a transfer station in Sedona? This can't be all on [the
City]...We should look at partners."
The City Council asked City staff to meet with representatives of
the Forest Service, Cottonwood, and Yavapai County about ways to
effectively partner to make a transfer station a reality on a
convenient location on National Forest land within the Sedona city
limits. |
|||||||
|
about us | privacy policy | advertise | bookmark this site copyright © 2006 Sedona.biz |